6.1. Petrography and mineralogy
The Taconite samples are porphyritic and in parts vesicular (e.g., C11-2) with a very fine-grained matrix formed of clinopyroxene, plagioclase, dispersed opaque iron oxides, and accessory apatite (
Fig. 6). Traces of biotite result from autohydrothermal alteration. Phenocrysts of probably former olivine are mostly replaced by aggregates of serpentine, calcite, chlorite, quartz, and iron oxides, often showing opaque or reddish rims, or are completely opacitized. To a smaller extent, phenocrysts of light-brownish clinopyroxene (sometimes forming glomerophyric aggregates) and rarely of plagioclase are present. The size of the phenocrysts range between 300 and 600 µm, rarely up to 2 mm. Amygdales are present in most samples in varying amounts and are filled with quartz and/or calcite (
Fig. 6). By XRD, the same minerals were detected in all samples in varying amounts (Supplementary Table S2). Major components are clinopyroxene, feldspar, and analcime. Iron oxides could be identified as hematite. Corrensite (a clay mineral with the formula (Mg, Al)
9 (Si, Al)
8O
20(OH)
10*4H
2O), quartz, calcite, anatase, and ± muscovite/illite were detected as minor components or traces. Olivine was not found by XRD. The composition of the basaltic rocks shows that they have experienced hydrothermal alteration that has affected mainly the olivine and a probable interstitial glass phase. This process started already coeval with the extrusion due to the interaction of the lava with water.
6.2. 40Ar/39Ar whole-rock age
Due to the fine-grained size of the matrix and the scarcity of plagioclase phenocrysts, no separation of mineral phases or matrix was possible. Ar–Ar whole-rock dating on volcanic rocks, which show some effects of hydrothermal alteration (as described above) and very low K
2O concentrations (<0.2 wt.%;
Table 2) is problematic (e.g.,
Jiang et al. 2021). However, our aim was the geochronological correlation of our samples to known magmatic events in northern Ellesmere Island, which have very distinct ages far away from each other. These are the Ordovician magmatism including the Thores Suite of Pearya Succession 3 (
Fig. 2a), the Carboniferous to Permian rift-related magmatism of the Sverdrup Basin and the Cretaceous HALIP-related magmatism (
Fig. 1).
The results of
40Ar/
39Ar whole-rock dating on three out of the four selected samples are presented in
Fig. 7. The complete Ar–Ar isotope data are available in Supplementary Table S1. The low K
2O concentrations of the dated samples and some alteration effects probably related to the Taconite River Fault Zone could have affected the quality of the Ar–Ar isotope data by Ar loss or Ar excess. To evaluate our Ar–Ar results, we use the quality criteria mentioned by
Koppers et al. (2000). Our data do not fulfill two of the criteria: the inverse isochron calculation did not provide ages and initial
40Ar/
36Ar values due to the large error ellipses of the apparent ages. However, our samples show high‐temperature plateaus in the age spectra, which include more than three incremental heating steps representing at least 50% of the total amount of
39Ar
K released (Supplementary Table S1). Additionally, their MSWDs are within an acceptable range given the number of data points (i.e., temperature steps) for each plateau. Furthermore, two of the samples use 100% of the released Ar for their age. Therefore, we believe that statistically our results are acceptable.
The age spectra of samples C11-1 and C11-4 yielded well-defined plateaus, which include 100% of the
39Ar released, with ages of 298 ± 12 Ma (1σ; MSWD = 0.74) and 289 ± 14 Ma (1σ; MSWD = 0.70), respectively (
Fig. 7). The spectrum of sample C11-5 is more disturbed, but the middle and high temperature steps provide a plateau age of 280 ± 15 Ma (1σ; MSWD = 1.13). For all three samples, the highest two temperature steps with c. 30% of the
39Ar released and relatively constant low Ca/K ratios (c. 18–25) yielded relatively constant apparent ages indicating degassing of plagioclase. Sample C11-8 yielded a disturbed spectrum with a plateau age of 240 ± 18 Ma (MSWD = 1.8; 61.7% of the
39Ar released). In contrast to sample C11-5, the plateau is formed by the low and middle temperature steps and thus is not related to the degassing of plagioclase but of newly formed K-bearing mineral phases (Supplementary Table S1).
The outcrop situation as well as the petrographic and geochemical similarity (see below) of the dated samples suggest a coeval extrusion of the lava. Thus, we exclude sample C11-8 from the age calculation, because its Ar isotope system was probably stronger affected by alteration as indicated by the low to middle temperature steps forming the plateau.
The plateau ages of the remaining three samples overlap within error. The average of 290 ± 19 Ma (2σ) is considered currently to represent the best estimate for the extrusion age of the Taconite volcanics. Despite the large error, this age span indicates that the volcanism was active during the second phase of the formation of the Sverdrup Basin in the early Permian or already in the late Carboniferous. Thus, the Ar–Ar age of the Taconite volcanics differs clearly from Ordovician and Cretaceous magmatic events in northern Ellesmere Island. The neighboring Sverdrup sediments were deposited during late Carboniferous to early Permian (c. 315–293 Ma). However, the Taconite volcanic rocks were not present within these sediments. The Taconite volcanics might have extruded on the rift shoulder formed by Ordovician Pearya basement rocks. Thus, stratigraphy gives only limited information about the age of volcanism.
6.3. Whole-rock geochemistry and rock classification
Major and trace element concentrations of the Taconite samples are presented in
Table 2. The samples have moderate LOI values (3.6–6.5 wt.%). For graphic presentation and comparisons, the major element oxides were recalculated to an LOI-free basis (see also Supplementary Table S3). The major element oxides show narrow ranges. The samples are characterized by low SiO
2 (41.2–43.8 wt.%) and alkali elements (1.92–2.17 wt.% Na
2O; <0.25 wt.% K
2O), as well as high MgO (11.2–12.7 wt.%), CaO (10.5–12.6 wt.%), total Fe
2O
3 (11.9–15.5 wt.%), Al
2O
3 (12.8–13.4 wt.%), TiO
2 (3.25–3.31 wt.%), and P
2O
5 (0.53–0.57 wt.%). An exception is sample C11-2 with higher SiO
2 (51.9 wt.%) and alkali elements (2.76 wt.% Na
2O, 0.72 wt.% K
2O), whereas MgO (8.1 wt.%) and CaO (7.2 wt.%) are lower. This sample is strongly porphyritic and rich in vesicles filled with quartz, which might explain the higher SiO
2 values, indicating stronger overprint by later hydrothermal fluids. This sample is shown in the geochemical diagrams but was not considered for genetic interpretations.
Following International Union of Geological Sciences (IUGS) recommendations (
Le Maitre 2002), most samples can be classified as picrite due to their high MgO (>12 wt.%) and low alkali-oxide concentrations (<3 wt.%) (
Fig. 8). Only sample C11-7 with MgO of 11.2 wt.% is a picrobasalt and the hydrothermally affected sample C11-2 with the highest SiO
2 content plots into the basalt field of the TAS diagram (
Le Maitre 2002). The picritic rocks are characterized by high Mg-numbers (mg# = molar MgO/MgO + FeO; Fe
3+/Fe
2+ = 0.15) of 0.64–0.70 and concentrations of Cr of 450–620 ppm and Ni of 220–260 ppm. Basalt sample C11-2 has the lowest mg# (0.59) and Ni concentration (180 ppm), whereas Cr (470 ppm) is in the range of the picrites. The high Nb/Y ratios of 2.54–4.10 indicate alkaline character for all samples (Nb/Y > 0.67;
Winchester and Floyd 1977;
Pearce 1996).
On a chondrite-normalized REE diagram, the samples show little variation. Their patterns have a negative slope (La
n/Yb
n = 19.6–28.0) and run almost parallel to the reference OIB pattern (
Fig. 9a). The light REE (La–Nd) are slightly enriched compared to OIB. In contrast to the typical OIB pattern, Yb and Lu are hardly fractionated, Lu
n is even higher than Yb
n in some samples (C11-1, -2, -6, and -7).
On a primitive mantle-normalized trace element diagram, all samples overlap well with the reference OIB pattern. However, the Taconite samples show large depletion in Rb, K, Hf, and enrichment in Cs, Ba, Nb, Ta, Pb and light REE (
Fig. 10). Due to the Ba–Ta enrichments, the patterns clearly have Th–U troughs, even though the concentrations of Th and U are close to those of the reference OIB.
On the V–Ti diagram from
Shervais (1982), all samples plot in the field of OIB and alkali-basalt (
Fig. 11a). V varies between 205 and 335 ppm at relatively high constant Ti concentrations, probably related to variations of total Fe that shows a positive correlation trend with V. The Taconite samples plot in the range of OIB showing enrichment in Nb and slightly elevated Nb/Yb ratios (
Figs. 10,
11b, and
11c).
In summary, most Taconite samples are alkali picrites, sample C11-7 is an alkali-picrobasalt and sample C11-2 that is rich in vesicles filled mainly with quartz is hydrothermally affected and will be not used for petrogenetic interpretation. They all have OIB-type incompatible element (including REE) concentrations with moderate enrichments of Ba, Nb, Ta, Pb, light REE and depletions of Rb, K, and Hf compared to OIB.